Good Doggie! vs What Happened To Your Toy?

Lucy is usually very good about not tearing apart her stuffed toys. Ever morning when I come home she will carry Rudy Reindeer around the house along with Aqua dog, and "bury" them in the corners of the couch, by the bookshelf etc. For Christmas, Santa Paws brought Lucy a really cute stuffed elf type toy. To my dismay, she had him torn apart, stuffing all over the place within minutes. I was quite disappointed in the quality of that toy.